When reviewing a paper, use the following headings as guidelines.
Post the review to your blog up to midnight before class.
| Paper Title | Title |
| Author(s) | Author(s) |
| Date | Date and/or conference |
| Summary | A one or two sentence summary of the paper. |
| Novel Idea | Describe in a sentence or two the new ideas presented in the paper. Include assumptions made, arugment made. |
| Main Result(s) | Describe in a sentence or two the main results obtained in the paper. |
| Impact | What is the importance of these results. What impact might they have on theory or practice of Computer Systems |
| Evidence | What reasoning, demonstration, analytical or empiricial analysis did they use to establish their results |
| Prior Work | What previously established results does it build upon and how |
| Competitive work | How to the compare their results to related prior or contemporary work |
| Reproducibility | Could you reproduce the findings? If so, how? If not, why not? |
| Question | A question about the work to discuss in class |
| Criticisms/Limiations | A criticism of the work that merits discussion. Alternatively, name any limitations that limits the impact and scope of this work. |
| Ideas for further work | Did this paper give you ideas for future work, projects, or connections to other work? (Hint: this is not the paper's Future Work section, write here IF the paper inspired any ideas in you!) |
