Lightweight Diagramming for Lightweight Formal Methods: A Grounded Language Design
Siddhartha Prasad, Ben Greenman, Tim Nelson, Shriram Krishnamurthi
European Conference on Object-Oriented Programming, 2025
Abstract
Tools such as Alloy enable users to incrementally define, explore, verify, and diagnose specifications for complex systems. A critical component of these tools is a visualizer that lets users graphically explore generated models. As we show, however, a default visualizer that knows nothing about the domain can be unhelpful and can even actively violate presentational and cognitive principles. At the other extreme, full-blown custom visualization requires significant effort as well as knowledge that a tool user might not possess. Custom visualizations can also exhibit bad (even silent) failures.This paper charts a middle ground between the extremes of default and fully-customizable visualization. We capture essential domain information for lightweight diagramming, embodying this in a language. To identify key elements of lightweight diagrams, we ground the language design in both the cognitive science research on diagrams and in a corpus of 58 custom visualizations. We distill from these sources a small set of orthogonal primitives, and use the primitives to guide a diagramming language called Cope-and-Drag (CnD). We evaluate it on sample tasks, three user studies, and performance, and find that short CnD specifications consistently improve model comprehension over the Alloy default. CnD thus defines a new point in the design space of diagramming: a language that is lightweight, effective, and driven by sound principles.
Blog
See our post for a quick overview.Paper
These papers may differ in formatting from the versions that appear in print. They are made available only to support the rapid dissemination of results; the printed versions, not these, should be considered definitive. The copyrights belong to their respective owners.