(copy to editor, edit, hand in to appropriate asgns directory with
filename AUTHOR_by_REVIEWER.txt).  Comments should be constructive and 
addressed to the author.

Requirements Author:
Project Title:
Reviewer:

Evaluate the following criteria on a scale from 1-5.  Add comments after each

OVERALL EVALUATION (1-5):
USEFUL TO OTHERS:
HAS SPECIFIC USERS:
CAN BE SCALED UP TO PC-SCOPE PRODUCT:
DIVISIBLE:
WELL DEFINED ENOUGH TO IMPLEMENT:
IN C++ ON SUNS:

are sources clear for requirements?
is are there good criteria for testing?

Other comments:

================================================================

Additional comments/changes after presentation: