I sometimes tell new tango dancers, "it's not so much where your feet are going, but how you're getting to the next step." It's the posture, the windup, the compression into the floor, the speed/slowdown of the middle of the motion that makes tango really look like tango (even if you're just walking forward). Likewise, I often tell my violin students, "it's not so much where your finger lands [even though that's important], but how you get to the next note. I want graceful finger motion!" because every time, improving the quality of the movement improves intonation also--and improves it in a natural way that comes out of having great posture and beautiful motion.
This summer I've been working on improving the frame of my hand by playing Suzuki Book 1 in octaves (only because I just can't get myself to practice scales). I've also been working on comfortable shifting technique by playing everything in Book 1 up an octave or an octave plus a fifth or whatever necessary to practice fairly challenging shifts. In doing both of these exercises, I'm most interested in getting to the next note gracefully.
Last time I learned to play the violin, graceful motion was not stressed. In the beginning, I know my teachers made sure my fingers were going down right, etc., but when I got to a lot of the advanced stuff I just muscled my way through it. This time around, I lack muscle, so I have to do it with technique. And you know, it takes far less time and work to master things like shifting and hand frame when I'm concentrating on posture and graceful motion.
Yesterday I started playing the Fugue from Bach's Sonata #1 for unaccompanied violin, to see how my left hand is doing. The Fugue is a doozy of a finger-twister, with double-, triple-, and quadruple-stops all over the place, and countermelodies (being a fugue...) woven through the melody so thoroughly that I often wonder why the heck Bach didn't just write the thing for 2 violins and save the poor solo violinist all of this agony. Anyway. I never quite mastered it as a first-time violin student and never enjoyed hearing myself play it--it was too choppy with all of the wild jumping around in the left hand.
So yesterday, as a second-time violin student who now has beautiful posture and has been thinking about graceful finger movement, I realized that I'm the teacher I needed the first time around--someone who could show me that this fugue is not about torturing the violinist, but about figuring out how to achieve finger motion so beautiful and natural that playing this ridiculous number of notes actually feels comfortable and fun. I paused in measure 4 at the end of the phrase (F# and C) to think about the beginning of the next phrase, wondering how I could use my new technique to make the passage beautiful instead of abrupt. For a change. Hmmmm.
As I later told L., I had my first and second fingers down and was thinking maybe instead of letting go with my whole hand, I could sort of sneak the third finger underneath the other two fingers and then, with the third finger down, release the other fingers to let my hand expand into position for the next triple-stop. At that moment, I had this vision of me sitting on the climbing wall at Mission Cliffs, knowing that my free foot had to sort of fold itself under me into some totally uncomfortable position in order to get to the next foothold--a position so weird and unnatural-looking that I couldn't believe that I was supposed to do it. But if I just relaxed and went for it (gracefully), the instant it connected, the rest of my body could pivot on that new foot into the next, comfortable position I needed. The motions are exactly the same for the violin, but with smaller appendages. :-)
Now I totally love this fugue, and have to take a hold of the reins and not work on it too much, for fear of tendonitis, and am already thinking maybe I can go have a lesson on it with G. so we can talk technique. Whee!